I’m about to submit proposals to clean up the anthropology terms that use “Primitive.”
I already did similar work on https://cataloginglab.org/kb/art-primitive/
H/T to the proposal for Nobel savage stereotype in literature which I used as a pattern: https://cataloginglab.org/kb/noble-savage-noble-savage-in-literature-revision/
Cancel:
Industries, Primitive
Primitive property
Primitive societies
Primitive societies $xFood
Revise AAP:
Change AAP Primitive societies in literature to Primitive man stereotype in literature
Other revisions:
Material culture
Industries
Property
Ethnic food
Anthropology
Prehistoric peoples$xFood
Industries, Prehistoric
Prehistoric peoples
Technological complexity
Pottery, Prehistoric
Cordage, Prehistoric
Matting
Nets
Type of Proposal | Cancelation note | No. of bib records changed | |
Industries, Primitive | Cancel | $i This authority record has been deleted because the heading is covered by the subject headings $a Industries $0 sh 85065960 | 199 |
Primitive property | Cancel | $i This authority record has been deleted because the heading is covered by the subject headings $aProperty $0 sh 85107496 | 48 |
Primitive societies | Cancel | $i This authority record has been deleted because the heading is covered by the subject heading Anthropology $0 sh 85005581 and Prehistoric peoples $0 sh 85080302 | 827 |
Primitive societies ǂx Food | Cancel | $i This authority record has been deleted because the heading is covered by the subject headings Ethnic food $0 sh2017004818 and Prehistoric peoples$xFood $0 sh 85080303 | 8 |
=LDR 00425cz a2200157n 4500
=001 sh\94008648\
=003 DLC
=005 19960912095948.9
=008 941115\|\anannbabn\\\\\\\\\\|a\ana\\\\\\
=010 \\$ash 94008648
=035 \\$a(DLC)sh 94008648
=035 \\$a(DLC)210795
=040 \\$aDLC$cDLC$dDLC
=150 \\$aPrimitive man stereotype in literature
=450 \\$wnne$aPrimitive societies in literature
=450 \\$wnne$aMan, Primitive, in literature
=450 \\$wnne$aSociety, Primitive, in literature
=550 \\$aNoble savage stereotype in literature
=670 \\$aThe savage in literature: representations of ‘primitive’ society in English fiction 1858-1920, Brian V. Street, 1975: $b p.12 (“Popular fiction inevitably distorts the image it presents of ‘primitive’ man. For not only is the image derived from the scientific theories of the age, which have been rejected by science today as themselves distorted, but it is also conditioned by the nature of the medium itself. Such popular literature tended not to create ’rounded’ characters but rather stereotypes.”)
=670 \\$aCannibalising Traditions: Representation and Critique in Heart of Darkness, Anthony Fothergill, 1996 $b p. 102 (“[Conrad’s] erasure of precise location, of historical and ethnic specificity, gives to the native peoples he represents the appearance of the near-mythic. We are offered ‘natural man’ stripped of the accoutrements of social reality: eternally present, at one with nature, offering some kind of less to ‘us’. The translation into ‘primitive man’ becomes all the easier if we are not preoccupied with the specificities of the late nineteenth-century Congo but can let our imaginations freely inscribe the blank page of Otherness.”)
=670 \\$aOrigins of African Stereotypes in British Colonial Novels, Sarah L. Milbury-Steen, 1980$b (“…the image of the African as savage and primitive had long been a stock European opinion. This identification had its literary roots in the eighteenth century when ‘the noble savage’ and ‘the bestial savage’ became conventions of abolitionist and pro-slavery literature respectively.”)
=670 \\$aThe SAGE handbook of prejudice, stereotyping and discrimination, 2010$b (in article for Ethnocentrism and group realities: “Despite the fact that ethnocentric group realities are a human universal and may be grounded in evolution … Members of these societies were described as completely different from typical human beings, often as bestial, evil, and lust-ridden… French anthropologist Levy-Bruhl considered members of indigenous tribes to be ‘primitives’ lacking individuality.”)
=952 \\$aLC pattern: Noble savage stereotype in literature
=952 \\$aRecords changed: 12
=952 \\$aProposal made as part of a larger project to clean up the usage of the term “Primitive” in LCSH. The revision here is meant to retain the term but contextualize it as a stereotype in western literature, rather than identifying a group or groups of people as “primitive.” This is consistent with the pattern established with “Noble savage stereotype in literature.”
Other revisions:
=LDR 00955cz a2200205n 4500
=001 sh\85082061\
=003 DLC
=005 20150303101235.6
=008 860211i|\anannbabn\\\\\\\\\\|b\ana\\\\\\
=010 \\$ash 85082061
=035 \\$a(DLC)sh 85082061
=035 \\$a(DLC)79270
=040 \\$aDLC$cDLC$dDLC
=053 \0$aGN406$bGN442
=150 \\$aMaterial culture
=550 \\$wg$aCulture
=550 \\$aFolklore
=550 \\$aTechnology
=680 \\$iHere are entered works on the objects made or used by people, especially the folk artifacts produced by traditional methods, as well as techniques of their production. Works limited to the techniques of production of pre-literate and folk cultures are entered under$aIndustries, Primitive.$iWorks on the material culture of particular ethnic groups are entered under the name of the group with the subdivision$aMaterial culture,$ie.g.$aIndians of North America–Material culture.
=681 \\$iNote under$aIndustries, Primitive
=LDR 00545cz a2200205n 4500
=001 sh\85065960\
=003 DLC
=005 20150204100459.6
=008 030609i|\anannbabn\\\\\\\\\\|a\ana\\\\\\
=010 \\$ash 85065960
=035 \\$a(DLC)sh 85065960
=035 \\$a(DLC)5965800
=035 \\$a(DLC)sp 85065960
=035 \\$a(DLC)301047
=040 \\$aDLC$cDLC$dDLC
=150 \\$aIndustries
=360 \\$iheadings for individual types of industries, e.g.,$aConstruction industry
=450 \\$aIndustrial production
=450 \\$aIndustries, Primitive
=450 \\$wnne$aIndustry
=550 \\$wg$aEconomics
=LDR 00573cz a2200241n 4500
=001 sh\85107496\
=003 DLC
=005 20060721132434.0
=008 060710i|\anannbabn\\\\\\\\\\|b\ana\\\\\\
=010 \\$ash 85107496
=035 \\$a(DLC)sh 85107496
=035 \\$a(DLC)5326680
=035 \\$a(DLC)sp 85107496
=035 \\$a(DLC)268538
=035 \\$a(DLC)6900708
=035 \\$a(DLC)345090
=040 \\$aDLC$cDLC$dDLC
=150 \\$aProperty
=450 \\$aPrimitive property
=450 \\$aProperty$xLaw and legislation
=550 \\$wg$aEconomics
=550 \\$aPossession (Law)
=550 \\$aThings (Law)
=550 \\$aWealth
=LDR 00432nz a2200133n 4500
=001 sh2017004818
=005 20180130095023.5
=008 171101i|\anannbabn\\\\\\\\\\|a\ana\\\\\\
=010 \\$ash2017004818
=040 \\$aDLC$beng$cDLC
=150 \\$aEthnic food
=450 \\$aPrimitive societies$xFood
=550 \\$wg$aFood
=670 \\$aWork cat.: We eat what?, 2017:$bIntro. (survey of ethnic foods with uncommon ingredients)
=670 \\$aReader’s guide, viewed Nov. 1, 2018$b(subject term: ethnic foods)
=LDR 00528cz a2200169n 4500
=001 sh\85005581\
=003 DLC
=005 19960920111745.2
=008 860211i|\anannbabn\\\\\\\\\\|b\ana\\\\\\
=010 \\$ash 85005581
=035 \\$a(DLC)sh 85005581
=035 \\$a(DLC)5349
=040 \\$aDLC$cDLC$dDLC
=053 \0$aGN
=150 \\$aAnthropology
=360 \\$iindividual races, tribes, etc., e.g.$aCaucasian race; Guayaki Indians;$iand subdivisions$aEthnic relations$iand$aRace relations$iunder names of countries, cities, etc.
=450 \\$aPrimitive societies
=550 \\$aHuman beings
=LDR 00400cz a2200169n 4500
=001 sh\85080303\
=003 DLC
=005 19960910150014.4
=008 860211i|\anannbabn\\\\\\\\\\|a\ana\\\\\\
=010 \\$ash 85080303
=035 \\$a(DLC)sh 85080303
=035 \\$a(DLC)77566
=040 \\$aDLC$cDLC$dDLC
=053 \0$aGN799.F6
=150 \\$aPrehistoric peoples$xFood
=450 \\$aPrimitive societies$xFood
=550 \\$wg$aFood
=550 \\$aAgriculture, Prehistoric
=LDR 00412nz a2200157n 4500
=001 sh\94009069\
=003 DLC
=005 19950111113222.4
=008 941129i|\anannbabn\\\\\\\\\\|a\ana\\\\\\
=010 \\$ash 94009069
=035 \\$a(DLC)sh 94009069
=035 \\$a(DLC)211181
=040 \\$aDLC$cDLC
=150 \\$aIndustries, Prehistoric
=450 \\$aIndustries, Primitive
=450 \\$aPrehistoric industries
=670 \\$aWork cat.: 94-44464: The emergence of pottery, 1995.
=LDR 01437cz a2200337n 4500
=001 sh\85080302\
=003 DLC
=005 20080519101954.0
=008 080404i|\anannbabn\\\\\\\\\\|a\ana\\\\\\
=010 \\$ash 85080302
=035 \\$a(DLC)sh 85080302
=035 \\$a(DLC)7500034
=035 \\$a(DLC)sp 85080302
=035 \\$a(DLC)395197
=040 \\$aDLC$cDLC$dDLC
=053 \0$aGN700$bGN890
=150 \\$aPrehistoric peoples
=450 \\$aCavemen (Prehistoric peoples)
=450 \\$aEarly man
=450 \\$wnne$aMan, Prehistoric
=450 \\$aPrehistoric archaeology
=450 \\$aPrehistoric human beings
=450 \\$aPrehistoric humans
=450 \\$aPrehistory
=450 \\$aPrimitive societies
=550 \\$wg$aHuman beings
=550 \\$aAntiquities, Prehistoric
=670 \\$aAcad. Am. encyc., 1994$b(Prehistoric humans)
=670 \\$aAmericana, 1995$b(Prehistoric human beings; Prehistory)
=670 \\$aBritannica Micro.$b(Prehistoric peoples and cultures; Prehistoric archaeology)
=670 \\$aWikipedia, April 4, 2008:$b(cavemen: popular stock character based upon stereotyped concepts of the way in which early prehistoric humans or homininans may have looked and behaved; often shown as living in caves; but this stemmed from the ritual paintings found in caves: it is more probable that the caves were religious gathering places or temporary shelter, and not the actual dwellings of the supposed “cavemen”)
=681 \\$iNote under$aAnthropology, Prehistoric
=LDR 00425nz a2200169n 4500
=001 sh\85133141\
=003 DLC
=005 19931126090301.2
=008 860211||\anannbabn\\\\\\\\\\|b\ana\\\\\\
=010 \\$ash 85133141
=035 \\$a(DLC)sh 85133141
=035 \\$a(DLC)128568
=040 \\$aDLC$cDLC$dDLC
=150 \\$aTechnological complexity
=450 \\$aComplexity, Technological
=550 \\$wgIndustries, Primitive
=550 \\$wg$aAnthropology
=LDR 00407cz a2200169n 4500
=001 sh\85105852\
=003 DLC
=005 19940105082819.9
=008 860211i|\anannbabn\\\\\\\\\\|b\ana\\\\\\
=010 \\$ash 85105852
=035 \\$a(DLC)sh 85105852
=035 \\$a(DLC)102190
=040 \\$aDLC$cDLC$dDLC
=053 \0$aGN799.P
=150 \\$aPottery, Prehistoric
=450 \\$aPrehistoric pottery
=550 \\$wg$aIndustries, Primitive
=550 \\$wg$aIndustries, Prehistoric
=LDR 00408nz a2200169n 4500
=001 sh\85032558\
=003 DLC
=005 19931126085638.0
=008 860211i|\anannbabn\\\\\\\\\\|b\ana\\\\\\
=010 \\$ash 85032558
=035 \\$a(DLC)sh 85032558
=035 \\$a(DLC)31456
=040 \\$aDLC$cDLC$dDLC
=053 \0$aGN799.C49
=150 \\$aCordage, Prehistoric
=450 \\$aPrehistoric cordage
=550 \\$wg$aIndustries, Primitive
=LDR 00359nz a2200157n 4500
=001 sh\85082258\
=003 DLC
=005 19931126085955.9
=008 860211||\anannbabn\\\\\\\\\\|b\ana\\\\\\
=010 \\$ash 85082258
=035 \\$a(DLC)sh 85082258
=035 \\$a(DLC)79466
=040 \\$aDLC$cDLC$dDLC
=053 \0$aTS1779.M2
=150 \\$aMatting
=550 \\$wg$aIndustries, Primitive
=LDR 00433nz a2200169n 4500
=001 sh\85091042\
=003 DLC
=005 19931126090040.9
=008 860211||\anannbabn\\\\\\\\\\|b\ana\\\\\\
=010 \\$ash 85091042
=035 \\$a(DLC)sh 85091042
=035 \\$a(DLC)87924
=040 \\$aDLC$cDLC$dDLC
=150 \\$aNets
=550 \\$wg$aIndustries, Primitive
=550 \\$wg$aMarine biology
=550 \\$wg$aZoological specimens$xCollection and preservation